sports

The Breakdown | Rattled All Blacks face rare twin threat as England eye back-to-back scalps

The Breakdown | Rattled All Blacks face rare twin threat as England eye back-to-back scalps

After their seismic defeat by Wales, New Zealand face the prospect of history repeating itself in unwanted ways They still talk about the last – and only – time the All Blacks have contrived to lose twice in succession to England. “There is so much talent in New Zealand that, if they don’t win the World Cup, there should be an inquiry,” opined Steve Hansen, Wales’s head coach at the time, ahead of England’s fateful visit to Wellington in the summer of 2003.

After their seismic defeat by Wales, New Zealand face the prospect of history repeating itself in unwanted ways

They still talk about the last – and only – time the All Blacks have contrived to lose twice in succession to England. Back in 2002-03, as now, there was a Rugby World Cup looming in Australia and New Zealand had no shortage of quality players. “There is so much talent in New Zealand that, if they don’t win the World Cup, there should be an inquiry,” opined Steve Hansen, Wales’s head coach at the time, ahead of England’s fateful visit to Wellington in the summer of 2003.

There’s a fresh inquiry under way now even before the All Blacks trot out of the Twickenham tunnel this weekend for the 48th meeting between the two nations. While Saturday’s 35-28 defeat to Wales ended a 73-year wait from a home perspective it has inevitably precipitated plenty of dark muttering back in the land of the long flat white.

Caught in the firing line, rightly or wrongly, are some big names including Beauden Barrett and Richie Mo’unga. Clearly the Cardiff calamity was not their sole fault but, equally, the shortage of clear-sighted tactical nous in the latter stages was glaring. Barrett, captaining his country for the first time, was winning his 149th cap. Whether he now reaches 150 this Saturday remains to be seen.

Of course there are reinforcements riding over the hill with Codie Taylor, Damian McKenzie, Cam Roigard, Jordie Barrett and others all ready to serve against England. Never underestimate, either, the stiffening of the sinews when New Zealand’s rugby reputation is on the line. “Pressure is a lifestyle when you’re in the All Blacks,” their forwards coach, Jason Ryan, said last year. “That’s the way it’s got to be.”

But still. While those two narrow losses in 2002 and 2003 clearly stung – and coincided with a prolonged Kiwi failure to win a World Cup until 2011 – it is necessary to rewind to 1999 to find the last occasion New Zealand lost in London and Cardiff on consecutive autumn weekends, the opposition being France and South Africa respectively.

Before that the last time they went down to Wales and England on the same tour of Europe was in 1935-36 when they found themselves toppled 13-12 in Cardiff and – unlucky for some – 13-0 at Twickenham. In other words Dave Rennie’s squad will find themselves in uncomfortable territory if they cannot bounce back immediately this Saturday.

Which All Black sides have mostly tended to do as a matter of routine. Remember when they lost 38-30 to Argentina in Wellington in 2024? Seven days later in Auckland they hammered the same opponents 42-10. The following year they lost again to the Pumas in Buenos Aires only to rebound and defeat South Africa in their very next fixture.

But is that familiar old black magic now at risk of fading to grey? South Africa deservedly won this year’s best-of-four Greatest Rivalry series 3-1 and New Zealand’s subsequent brace of Bledisloe Cup wins over the Wallabies no longer look quite so impressive given Australia’s increasing end-of-year travails.

It doesn’t help, either, that the centre Quinn Tupaea has broken a thumb and joined a lengthening injury list at the precise moment England are starting to stockpile more strength in depth. The Springboks had a good deal of scrummaging joy at New Zealand’s expense in August and September and the English maul, bolstered by the return of Maro Itoje and others, is also now re-emerging as a useful weapon.

So this could just be England’s chance to channel the old-school spirit of Martin Johnson’s erstwhile World Cup winners. And maybe it is a timely omen that this weekend Twickenham will also be staging the launch of a major new fundraising campaign, Front Up to MND, spearheaded by Lewis Moody who scored a try in that breathless 31-28 win over the All Blacks.

“My memories of that 2022 game are of getting knee-dropped and elbowed as I scored a try in the corner,” chuckled Moody, the former England captain who was diagnosed with motor neurone disease last year. “I had a really lovely try-scoring celebration lined up which I never got to perform because I was trying to locate my lungs after Chris Jack and Dougie Howlett both attempted to finish me off. But we ended up winning so in some respects it’s a very positive note on which to lead into this weekend.”

New Zealand, again as now, had several injury absentees but that was definitely not the case for the rematch in Wellington the following June. Richie McCaw, Carlos Spencer, Justin Marshall, Joe Rokocoko and Tana Umaga all started with Dan Carter, Mils Muliaina, Jerry Collins and Brad Thorn on the bench. Famously England were reduced to 13 men with Neil Back and Lawrence Dallaglio in the sin-bin but somehow clung on, in blustery wet conditions, to win 15-13 with Jonny Wilkinson contributing all the points.

It was nothing like as close 12 months ago when Steve Borthwick’s side roared back from 12-0 down to sweep aside Scott Robertson’s visitors 33-19. So deeply average were New Zealand that Robertson ended up being relieved of his coaching duties but the arrival of Rennie, after a promising start, has yet to bear much kiwi fruit in big games.

And the worst scenario of all? New Zealand lose this Saturday and find themselves in a second-place North v South playoff. When the opposition could easily be … England again. A thunderbolt loss of a defeat to Wales is one thing but then to follow it with two defeats in eight days to the bloody English? Let’s just say the All Blacks have heaps to play for.

This is an extract from our weekly rugby union email, the Breakdown. To subscribe just visit this page and follow the instructions.

  • blacks
  • england
  • wales
  • zealand
  • breakdown
  • threat
  • eye
  • defeat

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

All Blacks admit they ‘let country down’ against Wales and gear up for England
sports

All Blacks admit they ‘let country down’ against Wales and gear up for England

Rennie says team steeled for ‘more edge’ at Twickenham Head coach hopeful Jordan will be fit to play on wing The All Blacks head coach, Dave Rennie, has said the team “let ourselves down and let our country down” by losing to Wales and that he expects the match against England at Twickenham to have “more edge to it” as a result. Asked by an English journalist whether New Zealand would be able to brush off the game against Wales given they were missing so many first-choice players and will have them back on Saturday, Rennie said: “You’re obviously not a Kiwi, are you?”

Read →
Will Joseph poised to start for England against All Blacks after five-try burst
general

Will Joseph poised to start for England against All Blacks after five-try burst

Gloucester flyer excelled during thrashing of Japan Joseph in pole position for place on the wing Will Joseph is poised to be rewarded for his five-try heroics with another England start against the All Blacks on Saturday as Steve Borthwick’s team seek back-to-back victories against New Zealand for the first time since 2003. The Gloucester flyer has been in scintillating form all season and, after Immanuel Feyi-Waboso was struck down with injury against Australia, Borthwick wasted little time in turning to Joseph.

Read →
Police ‘retreating from streets’ due to major funding crisis, chief constables say
crime

Police ‘retreating from streets’ due to major funding crisis, chief constables say

Forces across England and Wales struggle amid financial pressures described as worst for decades Police chiefs say officers are “retreating from the streets” amid the worst financial crisis in decades, which has left nine forces seeking exceptional financial support (EFS) from the government. Paul Sanford, the chief constable of Norfolk police and the finance lead for the National Police Chiefs’ Council (NPCC), said exceptional financial support was needed if forces across England and Wales were to remain operationally viable.

Read →
Moeen Ali warns England ‘cannot win the World Cup’ by sidelining Adil Rashid
sports

Moeen Ali warns England ‘cannot win the World Cup’ by sidelining Adil Rashid

Leg-spinner made one appearance in recent tri-series Liam Dawson has retained place in Australia Adil Rashid has become a slightly peripheral figure in England’s white-ball plans this winter, with his close friend Moeen Ali openly criticising the management and warning it could damage their World Cup chances next year. While he began the Australia tour with figures of four for 35 in the warm-up match in Perth, Liam Dawson has remained the chosen spinner for the first two one-day internationals.

Read →
Max Dowman shines in England colours and sends another record tumbling
sports

Max Dowman shines in England colours and sends another record tumbling

Midfielder’s under-21s winner eclipsed Jude Bellingham’s mark and there was other talent to admire against France There may have been an Mbappé on the pitch – Ethan, the younger brother of Kylian, with whom he shares a near-identical gait – but by the end there was only one precocious talent on the lips of those watching England overcome France in their under-21s clash.

Read →