politics

The Guardian view on the Milburn report: a manifesto for youth participation

The Guardian view on the Milburn report: a manifesto for youth participation

In Europe, only Romania has a higher Neet rate. Alan Milburn’s message is that this amounts to a “moral crisis” which the British state must urgently address.

This is not a rerun of failed welfare cuts, but young people who rely on benefits cannot be expected to take promised opportunities on trust

The gap between the state’s investment in young people compared with older generations has more than doubled in two decades. At the same time, the number of 16- to 24-year-olds who are neither in education, employment or training (Neet) has climbed to 1 million. In Europe, only Romania has a higher Neet rate.

Alan Milburn’s message is that this amounts to a “moral crisis” which the British state must urgently address. Asked to write a review about young people and work, he has produced a “manifesto” for placing the broken social contract between generations at the heart of government. On Tuesday, his proposals for far-reaching changes to welfare, health, education and employment were on their way to becoming government policy as he was chosen to lead a new Youth Opportunities Unit.

While cuts to some benefits are part of the package, this doesn’t look like a rerun of the Starmer government’s ignominious failure to cut £5bn from the welfare bill. Its fiscal impact claims to be largely neutral, with spending on employment support offset by savings. Higher workforce participation is not expected to significantly reduce working-age benefits for a decade. Instead, the plan is to face down demands by the Tories and Reform UK to cut welfare spending and a poisonous narrative about workshy “snowflakes”, by persuading voters that what young adults need is help. Of the hundreds of young people he met, said Mr Milburn, “I have not found a single one who wanted to be Neet”.

A Youth Opportunity Service will be the new system’s “engine room”, offering wraparound support, including with health issues, to those who need it. Legislation will ensure that access to an adviser, and a job or training place, are guaranteed. Mayors will be responsible for delivery, making the new Neets service a core element of the devolution project.

Mr Milburn says that jobs must be created for the scheme to succeed, and draws unfavourable comparisons between the UK and countries that spend more on employment support relative to benefits. While he stops short of demanding that employer national insurance rises should be reversed, there is implied criticism of earlier decisions taken without sufficient regard to their impact. Presumably, his unit will take charge of a proposed “youth opportunity test”, whereby every new policy is examined from this perspective.

Ministers should expect the principle of age-linked entitlements to be challenged. Mr Milburn makes a good case for treating young adults without significant work experience or higher education as a distinct group. But 18- to 24-year-olds are adults, and there are legitimate objections to drawing lines in this way. Nor can people be expected to take it on trust that the new opportunities and allowances will be an adequate replacement for what they lose when they are moved off existing benefits. The Department for Work and Pensions has frequently failed to assess need fairly in the past. And while the proposal for waiting-time limits for mental health support is welcome, it points to a challenging reordering of NHS priorities.

This is not the only commitment that will be difficult to deliver. The need for cross-department cooperation will stretch Whitehall to its limits. But the emphasis on young people’s long-term prospects is positive, as is the decisive rejection of welfare cuts to bolster fiscal credibility. Youth participation is an overlooked form of inclusion. Increasing it is a sound principle for a Labour government.

  • milburn
  • manifesto
  • youth
  • people
  • guardian
  • view
  • report
  • participation

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Ministers vow to create new welfare system for young people as they back Milburn report
politics

Ministers vow to create new welfare system for young people as they back Milburn report

Government promises spending cuts to pay for the proposals, described by prime minister as ‘watershed moment’ UK politics live – latest updates Neet ideas: what’s in Milburn’s report? Ministers have promised to create an entirely new welfare system for young people as they gave their backing to Alan Milburn’s 278-page report, promising spending cuts next year to help pay for his proposals and giving him a government role to push them through.

Read →
Burnham considering cuts to national insurance to create more youth jobs
politics

Burnham considering cuts to national insurance to create more youth jobs

PM hints he is open to suggestion in Milburn report to lower NICs contributions paid by companies for under-25s Milburn urges Burnham to spend billions on young people Who are the Neets? UK youth job crisis in five charts Andy Burnham has said he would consider cuts to national insurance for young people “very carefully”.

Read →
The Guardian view on climate debt: a vicious cycle the world must break at Cop31
science

The Guardian view on climate debt: a vicious cycle the world must break at Cop31

Yet the Loss and Damage Fund, hailed as a historic breakthrough at the 2022 UN climate summit, has earmarked just $20m for Nepal – less than 5% of the $482m that Kathmandu must pay its external public creditors this year. “The scale of resources needs to increase,” Nepal’s delegation to this year’s UN climate conference drily observed.

Read →
Fresh off recent wins, the left has a new goal: get AOC to run for president
politics

Fresh off recent wins, the left has a new goal: get AOC to run for president

With its policy priorities more mainstream than ever, the left is directing its momentum toward 2028 A week after the US midterms elections swept an unprecedented number of leftists into office across the country, about 600 people joined a Zoom call. The goal: to convince rep Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to run for president.

Read →
Mahama calls for ECOWAS to become a community of the people, not just Heads of State
politics

Mahama calls for ECOWAS to become a community of the people, not just Heads of State

President John Mahama has called for a shift in focus within the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), insisting the regional bloc must evolve from an organisation dominated by Heads of State to one owned and driven by its citizens, particularly young people. Speaking at the West African Integration and Investment Summit (WAIIS) in Sierra Leone, President Mahama said it was time for citizens to take ownership of ECOWAS and actively participate in the regional integration process.

Read →