education

Macron banned smartphones in schools. A month later, France was ablaze. Could they be connected?

Macron banned smartphones in schools. A month later, France was ablaze. Could they be connected?

Macron banned smartphones in schools. A month later, France was ablaze.

French teachers argue that a digital detox woke students up to the decrepit state of their schools – and drove them out into the streets

Remember the 1999 blockbuster The Matrix? It may be more than a quarter of a century old, but it has become a byword and a meme for a frighteningly plausible kind of 21st-century tech dystopia.

A quick recap: the computer hacker Neo discovers that machines rule over humanity. They keep people trapped in pods, their minds immersed in a virtual reality designed to keep them docile (the “Matrix” of the title). Once he becomes aware of the world he actually inhabits, Neo decides to take up arms.

Is that the kind of awakening France’s youth is experiencing today? Could a government-mandated digital detox have had the unintended consequence of protests and riots on such a scale that the army was brought out on to the streets?

This October, hundreds of thousands of French youngsters have walked out of school and joined mass protests. Their demands include fixing France’s moribund school infrastructure and restoring every graduate’s right to choose their university and degree programme. Above all, they want to revive the école de la République, France’s public school system, as the engine of social mobility. Today only sport stars, crypto bros and influencers seem to be getting ahead in life.

These problems are nothing new. But what has triggered a reaction on this scale now?

Mara Goyet, a teacher in Paris, argues that the phone ban in lycées, introduced in September, helped spark the uprising. Suddenly disconnected from their own matrix, the pupils raised their eyes from their phone screens and could no longer tune out the grim reality of the world they inhabit, Goyet writes.

Emmanuel Macron decided to make the war on les écrans – screens – a legacy of his botched second term.

In 2024, the Élysée Palace asked a panel of experts, including neurologists and psychiatrists, to analyse the effects of digital technology on youth. It found that young French people aged 16 to 19 spent more than five hours a day staring at their phones. Shortened attention spans, a sedentary lifestyle and mental health issues were the consequence, the panel found.

Following the report, on 21 July the national assembly passed a law restricting social media access for under-15s and banning phones in lycées, coming into effect for the new school year. Perhaps paradoxically, the leftwing France Insoumise (LFI) had voted against the law, denouncing it as “a form of digital paternalism”. The far-right Rassemblement National abstained.

The constitutional court quickly overturned the social media ban. But when teenagers returned from their summer holidays, teachers were asking them to leave their phone in lockers or put them in sealed pouches.

A teacher working in a Parisian suburb, writing anonymously in Le Grand Continent, describes a classroom transformed: “As soon as the class, with its necessary tyranny, came to an end, the brains switched off. The 30 or so brains were drained by the image drug. My class became a group of zombies … This year, without their phones, my students are more lively, more engaging, more engaging, more disorganised, more excitable, more childlike. They’re also more of a pain.”

Another teacher told me much the same story: with the arrival of smartphones, breaktimes had grown quieter, with many pupils absorbed by their TikTok feed or playing games. Now, the hallways are loud again, buzzing with life.

For a shared political consciousness to form, people need to break out of isolation, talk to one another and build trust. That seems to have happened. And for pupils pushed back into the analogue world, political action goes beyond online posting and out into the streets.

Appropriately, the trigger for the French student movement that erupted into the era-defining protests of May 1968 was another interdiction: a ban on female and male students spending the night together in dormitories at the Nanterre campus, University of Paris.

By protesting as their forebears did in 68, today’s students also briefly disrupted what Guy Debord described as the “society of the spectacle”: a world in which reality is shaped by a flood of images, performative acts and mediated information. Here, by contrast, was the direct experience of reality. Standing together in the clouds of teargas that engulfed Paris and other cities on 17 October, a new generation of French citizens forged a collective lived experience that showed them they could be actors, not just spectators of political life.

Sociologists will have to study whether the enforced digital detox has really helped trigger this movement. After all, pupils have also organised their actions via social media, and the protests are extensively live-streamed on the same smartphones and platforms they have been detached from at school. This is a hybrid uprising.

But one thing is already clear. Students are not taking to the streets because they want to overturn the phone ban.

Louis Letoublon, vice-president of Les Lycéens!, an organisation of high school students, says: “The phone ban is unbearable, as it infantilises the students.” Some protest posters read: “Adult and vaccinated, but I am still getting my phone taken away at school.” Or: “You can take away my phone, but not my voice.”

But the government has set up a platform where pupils can register their demands. According to preliminary results based on more than 60,000 contributions, 70% said school days were too long, and 48.2% cited poor infrastructure, particularly the cold in winter and heat in summer. Only 9% of students demanded that the phone ban be overturned.

France’s young people took to the streets because they want better schools, not because they see Macron as an overbearing father, confiscating phones as punishment.

Two years ago, Macron declared that it was urgent to “retake control of our screens, that too often enclose us, where they should liberate us”. The irony is that, by unplugging teenagers from the matrix, he may have unleashed a storm that has sealed his decline and fall.

Joseph de Weck is an associate fellow with the German Council on Foreign Relations and writes for Guardian Europe from Zürich and Paris

  • macron
  • school
  • month
  • france
  • matrix
  • century
  • neo
  • smartphone

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news