crime

Mother, stepfather to stand trial over alleged murder of 12yo girl

Mother, stepfather to stand trial over alleged murder of 12yo girl

Tiffani Scholten was found unresponsive at her Gold Coast home in 2022, with her mother and stepfather charged over her alleged murder.

A trial will be held into the 2022 death of 12-year-old Tiffani Scholten, who police allege was murdered by her mother and stepfather.

Carrissa Scholten, 36, and Aaron Richardson, 37, stand charged with one count each of murder as a domestic violence offence.

The pair are due to face Brisbane's Supreme Court at a date yet to be determined.

A mother and her long-term partner have been committed to stand trial over the murder of her 12-year-old daughter, who allegedly died from malnourishment on the Gold Coast four years ago.

Carrissa Kay Scholten and Aaron Paul Richardson faced Southport Magistrates Court on Thursday, charged with the murder of Tiffani Jane Scholten.

The 12-year-old, who the court heard was severely disabled, was found unresponsive at their home on Bellagio Crescent in Coomera, Gold Coast, on April 18, 2022.

After a protracted homicide investigation, the girl's mother Carrissa Kaye Scholten and her partner Aaron Paul Richardson were charged with murder in August 2024.

Today, Magistrate Louisa Pink found there was sufficient evidence for the pair to stand trial.

Ms Scholten's sister, Cassandra Dunn, told the court that Mr Richardson's relationship with Carrissa Scholten was controlling and abusive.

"[He was] short-tempered and possessive," Ms Dunn said.

"He didn't like her hanging out with me; he didn't approve of that."

While she said there had been "a little altercation" between the couple physically, Ms Dunn told the court Mr Richardson had "snapped" in multiple phone calls and voicemails.

Ms Dunn told the court Mr Richardson was a cocaine dealer who had "a fake power point [electrical outlet] in the bedroom that he was stashing things in", which she said her sister had shown her.

She said she had heard that his "drug associates" were raided by police in the days leading up to Tiffani Scholten's death.

Ms Dunn said that Ms Scholten was too scared to seek medical help, over fears it would lead to investigations that could uncover Mr Richardson's alleged drug dealing.

"She was scared to take Tiffani to the hospital because of how Aaron would react," she told the court.

Southport Special School teacher aide, Brenda Walker, told the court she last saw Tiffani in December 2021 but that she did not return in 2022, missing 16 weeks of school.

Tiffani's teacher in 2021, Nicola Reid, told the court that Tiffani weighed 13 kilograms.

She said Ms Scholten told her that Tiffani had Rett syndrome — a rare neurological disorder that caused growth issues — but that "nobody could really confirm" the diagnosis.

Ms Reid told the court that unlike other students with Rett syndrome, Tiffani did not appear to physically or verbally deteriorate during 2021 and had a healthy appetite.

While the court heard Ms Scholten had attempted to feed Tiffani in the night leading up to her death, Justice Pink said: "There is evidence that she had not received medical care for a prolonged period before her death."

Both Mr Richardson and Ms Scholten declined to speak in court.

  • mother
  • murder
  • trial
  • girl
  • stepfather
  • tiffani
  • scholten
  • gold

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Regina Re, brother freed on Sh200,000 bail over mother’s murder
crime

Regina Re, brother freed on Sh200,000 bail over mother’s murder

NAIROBI, Kenya, Nov 18 — Former television presenter and actress Regina Re and her brother Antony Macharia have been released on Sh200,000 cash bail each after pleading not guilty to charges of being accessories to the murder of their 86-year-old mother, Dorita Lasinder Macharia. Regina, whose full name is Regina Wambui Macharia Gitao, and her brother are accused of interfering with the crime scene to conceal evidence and cover up the alleged involvement of Regina’s daughter, Thandie Malaika Wanjiku Gitao.

Read →
Member of anti-migrant group found guilty of Staffordshire murder
crime

Member of anti-migrant group found guilty of Staffordshire murder

Raise the Colours activist Billy Allison, 36, killed man in ‘completely unprovoked and unjustified’ attack, say police A member of anti-migrant group Raise the Colours has been found guilty of murdering a man in a “completely unprovoked and unjustified” attack. Billy Allison, 36, delivered a “very, very hard” punch with the “stance and skill of an experienced fighter” which killed 44-year-old Matthew O’Gara while he was on a night out in Lichfield on 24 May.

Read →