politics

The moral panic over Neets needs to stop. The problem is bad jobs, not young people

The moral panic over Neets needs to stop. The problem is bad jobs, not young people

The moral panic over Neets needs to stop. They’re the subject of Alan Milburn’s review, which, although not commissioned by Andy Burnham, has become the first big policy of his new government.

Milburn’s review doesn’t ask what kind of work young people will be going into: zero hours, minimum wage, mind-numbing. Do we have the guts to solve that?

One big number has been repeated over and over this week: 1 million. As ministers and journalists keep telling us, about 1 million 16- to 24-year-olds are not in education, employment or training (Neet). They’re the subject of Alan Milburn’s review, which, although not commissioned by Andy Burnham, has become the first big policy of his new government.

Rather than launch into my conclusions, let me give you three more numbers by which to judge Milburn for yourself. These figures have not appeared in any of this week’s coverage, but to understand the review’s context and its chances of success they are vital.

Let’s start with 1,500%. That is how much more the press talks about “economic inactivity” now, compared with 2017. Back then, a newspaper reader would barely see the phrase; by 2024, it was appearing literally thousands of times, often on front pages. There was a similar huge rise in the use of the term “sicknote”. From near-silence a few years ago, these phrases have become a daily drumbeat, sounded across print and broadcast. And their major motif is young people.

Yet it is not news, not even close. As Milburn says, the Neet rate has been roughly the same for a quarter of a century. This is a serious and long-lasting problem, rooted in economic and social failure, rather than a shock event. But Britain’s rightwing media is unrivalled at manufacturing an urgent crisis. A decade ago, they helped turn Brexit from a fringe obsession of men with red faces and pink trousers into a national referendum and then a racist reality. In the 2020s, they have done a number both on people seeking asylum here and youngsters out of work.

The 1,500% figure comes from James Morrison, who in his new book The Workless: Stigma, Unpaid Labour and the Myth of Economic Inactivity, charts a “moral panic”. Take the first lady of Reform UK, Isabel Oakeshott, laying into the “parasites” who “prefer to just sit on the sofa and order their Deliveroo and drive their Motability free vehicle and take everything that the state can offer”. Oakeshott delivered this reportage on a TV channel owned by the Australia-born American billionaire Rupert Murdoch, before herself leaving the UK tax system to live in Dubai. Parasites come in many shapes and sizes.

This rightwing moral panic over kids off work and playing Grand Theft Auto forms the backdrop against which Keir Starmer last year turned to Milburn. As Westminster reporters often remind us, Milburn is a grandee from the Blair years. As they are too discreet to mention, he also left his post as health secretary and went on to make millions from private equity healthcare. His review is that familiar Blairite tug of war between two opposing forces: an acceptance that poverty and inequality are “at the core” of the problem, and policies that strip many young disabled people of benefits and make them still poorer.

Our next number is 0, which stands for zero employees. Because the overwhelming majority of companies in this country have no staff. Think: Uber drivers, gas fitters, pilates instructors. These are sole traders. And here lies the problem for Milburn, who plans to pay employers to hire Neets. Of the £3.6bn of benefits taken off young people, £1.1bn will be handed to businesses that recruit them. But hardly any of those ideal companies exist.

Politicians still imagine the UK as a land of toolmakers and assembly lines. Burnham promises to “reindustrialise Britain”, while George Osborne pledged a “march of the makers”. In reality, our largest private employers include Tesco and Asda, and Amazon warehouses. There is a land dominated by Volkswagen and Siemens – it’s called Germany.

You can’t push people into jobs that aren’t there, offered by employers that don’t exist, in an economy that you’ve dreamed up. One of Milburn’s own surveys shows that only 17% of businesses think a Whitehall bung will prompt them to hire more young people than they otherwise would. Far more likely is that companies pocket the three grand for making the same hires they were going to make all along.

Our last number is 1 in 4. A quarter of all British jobs are “bad jobs”, calculates Kirsten Sehnbruch at the London School of Economics, marked by precarious contracts or crap pay and conditions. In London, the proportion of bad jobs rises to 1 in 3. That lump of bad jobs remains huge despite low unemployment, so market forces clearly aren’t working. However warm his words, Milburn expects Neets to take this kind of work: zero-hours contracts (which the new workers’ rights law will limit, not scrap), minimum wage, jobs that treat you like an automaton.

So what?, you may say: at least it’s a start. But after 20 years advising governments on labour markets, Sehnbruch has a rule: land in the “bad job” economy and you’re unlikely to get out. Universal credit forces you from one bad job into another, while there isn’t good state-subsidised training that would enable you really to get a leg up. Career ladder? Forget it.

On rare occasions, the government does accept this. When in 2017 the headlines were about Deliveroo drivers and Sports Direct warehouses, Theresa May asked another Blairite grandee, Matthew Taylor, to report on modern workplaces. Among his key findings was that British jobs were characterised by “one-sided flexibility”, where only the employers benefited from flexibility. Perhaps Taylor’s review offered too much realism for Westminster, because hardly any of its recommendations were made law.

The Milburn report and the moral panic out of which it emerged obsesses over how to get young people into work; it doesn’t ask what kind of jobs market they’re going into. Yet these last two figures show that Britain’s labour market is the opposite of that confected by Westminster and the press. Twenty-five per cent of workers are in bad jobs, largely subsidised by the taxpayer, with poverty pay topped up by the state; and about 20% of the working-age population are in no jobs, subsidised by the taxpayer. Milburn’s proposed mix of “work coaches” and three-grand bungs won’t do much to change that.

What would? Part of the answer lies in the two major goals Burnham has set himself: a council housebuilding boom and a national care service. Rather than hope in vain that Britain’s private sector will deliver these huge public goods, he should drive the public sector to deliver both directly – as they did before the “40 years of neoliberalism” that the prime minister rightly criticises. He should direct them to take on and train up a proportion of young people who want to join the workforce.

As the labour market researcher Thanos Angelopoulos points out, that would redirect taxpayer money away from landlords and private care agencies, lift millions of families out of bad accommodation and worries about care for their elderly and sick relatives, and provide significant public assets. It would also give good jobs to our next generation. Why not? It’s got to be better than a little tinkering before ordering up another review.

Aditya Chakrabortty is a Guardian columnist

  • people
  • milburn
  • review
  • panic
  • neets
  • problem
  • number
  • job

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Badenoch says using amputee athletes to justify cutting disability benefits was ‘message of hope’ – UK politics live
politics

Badenoch says using amputee athletes to justify cutting disability benefits was ‘message of hope’ – UK politics live

Kemi Badenoch was in a straight-talking mode on the media round this morning, calling the historic meeting between Trump, Xi and Putin “disturbing”, saying it looked like they were trying to “carve” up the world” between them. There are three world leaders who look like they’re trying to carve up the world between them, a tri-polar world where Xi gets Asia, America gets the western hemisphere and Russia gets Europe, and that is very concerning, especially seeing Donald Trump call President Putin his friend.

Read →
Lawyer calls for urgent review of Letby convictions after expert witness revelations
health

Lawyer calls for urgent review of Letby convictions after expert witness revelations

Failure to disclose Peter Hindmarsh’s exclusion from practice raises ‘fundamental questions’ over nurse’s case Lucy Letby’s lawyer has said the court of appeal must urgently review her convictions, after it was revealed that a key medical witness in the prosecution’s case was barred from treating patients because of safety concerns. The Guardian revealed this week that Prof Peter Hindmarsh – a crucial expert witness who provided an opinion at Letby’s trial that two babies had been poisoned with insulin – was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023 because his hospital considered him unsa

Read →
Brejoin? Is Andy Burnham going to reverse Brexit? – podcast
politics

Brejoin? Is Andy Burnham going to reverse Brexit? – podcast

Is Andy Burnham going to reverse Brexit? Deputy political editor Jessica Elgot and influential MEP David McAllister on the prospect of the UK rejoining the European Union, before Friday’s UK-EU summit On Friday, Andy Burnham will be in Brussels, to sign off a series of new deals between the UK and the EU.

Read →
Cap all political donations, not only those from overseas, Burnham told
politics

Cap all political donations, not only those from overseas, Burnham told

Experts say ‘insanely complex’ £100,000 limit proposed for overseas donors should be replaced by universal cap Andy Burnham is facing calls to commit to a cap on all political donations when the elections bill is in the House of Lords, instead of the “insanely complex” £100,000 limit on overseas donors. The Labour former home secretary David Blunkett is one of many peers to have tabled an amendment calling for an overall cap, proposing a £500,000 annual limit per donor, with his plan believed to have broad support.

Read →
[VIDEO] Drama As Ngige Urges Residents To Vote For APC ‘From Top To Bottom’ At Anambra Presidential Rally
politics

[VIDEO] Drama As Ngige Urges Residents To Vote For APC ‘From Top To Bottom’ At Anambra Presidential Rally

There was a mild drama at the All Progressives Congress (APC) presidential campaign rally in Anambra State on Thursday when a former governor of the state, Chris Ngige, urged residents to vote for the APC in the 2027 presidential, National Assembly, and House of Assembly elections. Ngige added that while people were free to choose between APGA and the APC, Anambra desires to be connected to the Federal Government at the centre and get it through the ruling party.

Read →
2027: Soludo urges Anambra voters to support APC, warns against political isolation
politics

2027: Soludo urges Anambra voters to support APC, warns against political isolation

Sekinat Osundiji Anambra State Governor, Prof. Chukwuma Soludo, has urged residents of the state to reconsider their voting pattern ahead of the 2027 presidential election, warning that political isolation could further weaken the South-East’s influence in national affairs. Soludo made the appeal on Thursday at the All Progressives Congress (APC) presidential campaign rally in Anambra State, attended by Vice-President Kashim Shettima, APC National Chairman and other party leaders and governors.

Read →