politics

Promise Me, America by Joe Biden review – former president defends his decisions

Promise Me, America by Joe Biden review – former president defends his decisions

New memoir tells of policy feats and battles with Trump but struggles to take responsibility for re-election debacle Inevitably, readers of Joe Biden’s new memoir will flick forward to find what he says about the events that ended his presidency: increasing pressure about his age and capacity that finally led him to stand aside and anoint Kamala Harris, too late, ushering fascism back to the White House. He raises Barack Obama’s poor performance in his first debate with Mitt Romney in 2012, when Biden was VP.

New memoir tells of policy feats and battles with Trump but struggles to take responsibility for re-election debacle

Inevitably, readers of Joe Biden’s new memoir will flick forward to find what he says about the events that ended his presidency: increasing pressure about his age and capacity that finally led him to stand aside and anoint Kamala Harris, too late, ushering fascism back to the White House. Alas, Biden thinks he was just fine to keep on serving and the whole thing was a stitch-up by a panicked party.

Of his catastrophic debate in June 2024, when the then 81-year-old president blinked, stuttered and gaped under the lights, Biden writes: “I knew the debate had gone badly. But I knew that debates had gone badly for lots of incumbent presidents. Especially their first ones. I left the stage thinking I would be debating Trump once more before the election was over. I was wrong. This wasn’t just the first debate, it was my last one.” He raises Barack Obama’s poor performance in his first debate with Mitt Romney in 2012, when Biden was VP. Caught cold, Obama prepared for the next one and cruised to re-election.

During his own debate, Biden was utterly lost, stuttering out: “We finally beat … Medicare.” He writes now that he meant “big pharma”, but a bad cold got the better of him. It’s just not enough. Biden writes a lot about taking responsibility. But he doesn’t. Prompted by his description of his wife’s support – “Get up. We’re not going to let 90 minutes define your career” – anyone with the stomach might turn to another book out this week, The East Wing by Azadeh Moaveni, for an account of First Lady Jill Biden’s role that dreadful summer, refusing to look fate in the eye. After that, anyone might reach for a very strong drink.

Readers might also choose other books’ proper accounts of other traumas, including Biden’s muddled interview with special counsel Robert Hur, who investigated Biden’s retention of classified information, and the legal travails of Biden’s son Hunter. Biden says Hur’s famous description of “an elderly man with a poor memory” was a political hit job. Hunter got a pardon. So did other family members, for protection against Donald Trump. The pardon power is an absurd anachronism in need of drastic reform. Perhaps we should thank Biden for making that so clear.

It’s less clear what Promise Me, America is really for. Biden’s third book, it is his third with “promise” in the title. Promises to Keep came out in 2007, when Biden was a Delaware senator preparing a second run for president. Promise Me, Dad dealt with the death of his son, Beau, at the end of Biden’s eight years as vice-president to Barack Obama, and laid the ground for his third presidential run.

What does Biden want America to promise him now? Maybe just to pony up 30 bucks one last time. The former president is 84. His cancer diagnosis hangs over his book, discussed with admirable candor.

The book is well written and well organized, if sometimes close to a recitation of Biden’s daybook as he won the White House in 2020, beating Trump; as he governed through four stormy years at home and abroad; as Trump loomed again; as Biden faltered and stumbled and finally stood down in a summer of disaster. Biden, as both a leader and writer, may be no Ulysses S Grant, author of the best presidential memoir. As a writer, or leader, he may be no Obama, a comparison that hangs silently over every part of Promise Me, America. But as a president, Biden did make his mark.

Though memories of his presidency have been swallowed by Trumpian chaos, most know Biden presided over major legislation to help the country (and the world, via vaccine programs) emerge from the ravages of Covid. Chapters about how the American Rescue Plan Act and Inflation Reduction Act got through Congress are rich reading as the Trump administration flails and fails amid systems outages and after a midterms beating.

A theory: Promise Me, America is the memoir of a man who became president but whose heart remained in the Senate. Biden was a senator 36 years, elected at 29 in 1972, known as “Amtrak Joe” for his habit of traveling by train from Delaware to DC and back, father to young sons left motherless when his wife, Neilia Biden, and daughter Naomi were killed in a car crash. When Biden became vice-president, he was 66. Steeped in the lore of the Senate, the back-room dealing and backslapping, he may even have managed to read all of Master of the Senate, Robert Caro’s doorstop about Lyndon Johnson, to whom Biden is often compared.

To pass the American Rescue Plan, Joe Manchin, of West Virginia, simply had to be won over. Biden relishes how it was done: “I called Joe [Manchin] to meet with me in the Oval Office… We were both Catholic politicians from the old school. Proud. Stubborn. But now it was time to lay our cards on the table. This was my first major legislative initiative. The American people needed relief. I needed him on this vote. I never considered myself a Lyndon Johnson-type president, who cajoled and threatened and even physically cowed legislators, but I was losing my temper. I told Joe that I needed him on this, and if he screwed me, I’d go to every county in West Virginia and tell them that Joe Manchin was why they weren’t getting any help. Joe came right back at me, reminding me that I wasn’t so popular in West Virginia. After a further exchange of words, Joe agreed to be with me and vote in favor.”

As a “Catholic politician from the old school”, Biden’s faith is never far from the surface. His forgiveness was strained by Manchin, who in December 2021 turned and shivved his president, going on Fox News to declare himself a no on the Build Back Better bill, sinking it. Biden also celebrates William Scranton, a Pennsylvania governor who Biden’s “grandpop” – a typically folksy phrase – held up as a politician who “smacks you on the back, like he’s your best friend … and it’s not until you’re about a block or so from his house that you notice the feeling of warm blood running down your back. That, Joey, is what we call a ‘silk stocking screw’.”

Alas, as the Manchin episode shows, Biden is a backslapper but, fatal for any politician, a nice guy, no sort of killer at all. Tales of stern statesmanship end up undercut. Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, reportedly raised Biden to anger amid genocide in Gaza after the Hamas attacks of 7 October. And yet as Biden’s book was released, the Jerusalem Post reported that a transcript of the two men’s final conversation showed the American president ladling on the praise: “I can’t tell you how much I appreciate you and what you’ve been through … I still love you, pal … you’re a good man … I admire you. It took a lot of courage to do what you did.” To those who lament Biden’s inability or refusal to rein Netanyahu in, it rang depressingly true.

Dealt a tough hand, Biden played it … varyingly. Russia invaded Ukraine. Biden describes how he marshalled support for Kyiv, which he visited in secret, an episode vividly retold. Now, the war is nearly five years old, Trump wants to end it on Russia’s terms, and Biden inexplicably chooses to chastise Volodymyr Zelenskyy for not being “grateful”, an unfortunate echo of Trump and JD Vance attacking the Ukrainian president in the Oval Office. When Biden occupied that space, sitting behind the Resolute Desk (which like all presidents he likes to repeat, to show how, y’know, resolute he is), Biden committed to withdraw from Afghanistan after 20 futile years.

It was the right decision, but the pull-out was botched. Describing his devastation at the deaths of 13 US service members in a suicide bombing in Kabul, Biden skips the furore when, at Dover air force base in Delaware for the dignified transfer of remains, cameras caught him looking at his watch. Grieving parents also said he spoke about Beau more than about their lost children. The ferocity of fire was unfair, some of it partisan for sure, but these were avoidable problems.

Two years have passed. Daily, Trump commits outrages against the decency his predecessor stands for. But Biden’s book comes out in a landscape altered by Democrats’ midterms tsunami. Presidential contenders are starting to jostle. Promise Me, America reads like a message from the old world. Maybe a warning, about mistakes not to be remade. All the way through, the words of another figure from more genteel circles ring clear.

In November 2020, shortly before Biden beat Trump, former British ambassador Kim Darroch told the New Statesman: “What we used to say inside the embassy about Joe Biden – to be indiscreet – was he is certainly past his best and his best was never that great.”

  • biden
  • president
  • debate
  • joe
  • election
  • america
  • review
  • memoir

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Vance stops short of endorsing Trump’s claim that Iran was close to nuclear weapon
politics

Vance stops short of endorsing Trump’s claim that Iran was close to nuclear weapon

US vice-president says it’s not his place to second-guess the president, but refrains from endorsing Trump’s claim At a White House news conference on Friday, JD Vance stopped short of endorsing Donald Trump’s claim that Iran was so close to obtaining a nuclear weapon in February that it was essential for the US to go to war with the Islamic republic. In the White House briefing room, Trump was asked about reporting this week that he was unhappy with the US vice-president’s statement blaming Republican losses in the midterm elections on the Iran war.

Read →
Trump turns White House press conference into a 2028 succession audition
politics

Trump turns White House press conference into a 2028 succession audition

The president appeared to put Vance and Rubio through their paces as potential successors, though Stephen Miller unexpectedly stole the spotlight “Which of you shall we say doth love us most?” The ageing King Lear’s question to his daughters, expecting them to compete for his favour and carve up his kingdom, hovered in the White House press briefing room on Friday.

Read →
Trump threatens ‘tremendous penalties’ on US tech firms that build datacenters abroad
politics

Trump threatens ‘tremendous penalties’ on US tech firms that build datacenters abroad

President gives wide-ranging White House press conference and says he has ‘fantastic relationships’ with Putin and Xi Donald Trump threatened on Friday to impose “tremendous penalties” on American tech companies that build datacenters outside the US, though he gave no details and told reporters he had not yet informed his own officials about the plan. In a discursive press conference from the White House briefing room, Trump also said he would “look into” the report that Iran had been planning to possibly detonate a “dirty bomb” in Washington DC, and backed JD Vance over comments the vice-pres

Read →