politics

Justice Lifu’s judgment, Atiku’s fate and the road to 2027

Justice Lifu’s judgment, Atiku’s fate and the road to 2027

The judgment delivered on November 5, 2026, by Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court, Abuja, in Suit No. Its lawyer, Kalu Kalu, SAN, argued on national television thus: “The judgment of Honourable Justice Peter Lifu does not in any way void the candidacy of Atiku Abubakar… No portion of that judgment voids the candidacy of Atiku Abubakar and other candidates of the party.”

By Tunde Rahman Some judgments settle a dispute. Some judgments can reorder a nation’s politics. The judgment delivered on November 5, 2026, by Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court, Abuja, in Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025 – Nafiu Bala Gombe versus African Democratic Congress and Others – belongs to the second category. That judgment did not just decide who leads a party.

It has placed former Vice President Atiku Abubakar’s presidential ambition and the future of the ADC in suspense, and perhaps created a crisis of perception for the 2027 general election. What did the court actually decide? Let me state from the get-go that neither the All Progressives Congress nor President Bola Tinubu filed the case. A member of the ADC itself– Nafiu Bala Gombe, the former Deputy National Chairman (North-East), – filed it.

Gombe argued that after the former National Chairman, Ralph Nwosu, resigned, leadership should have devolved to him under the party’s constitution. Instead, he argued, a caretaker leadership led by former Senate President David Mark and former Osun Governor Rauf Aregbesola was imposed at the 99th National Executive Committee meeting on July 27, 2025, without a democratic election.

Justice Lifu agreed with him. Among other things, the judge held that David Mark’s emergence as National Chairman and Rauf Aregbesola’s emergence as National Secretary were unlawful. He also stated that Nafiu Bala Gombe’s purported resignation letter was fictitious. After comparing the signatures on the letter with Gombe’s sworn witness statements, the judge found material differences and held that the document could not be relied upon.

Justice Lifu then ordered that all actions, decisions, and steps taken by the David Mark-led National Working Committee from July 27, 2025, are null, void, and without effect, and that the Independent National Electoral Commission should not recognise the Mark-led leadership. The legal anchor was Section 82 (3) of the Electoral Act 2022, which requires political parties to elect their officers democratically.

According to Justice Lifu, neither a NEC resolution nor INEC’s administrative recognition could substitute for that statutory requirement. This is how the judgment affects former Vice President Atiku Abubakar. Admittedly, Atiku was not a party to the suit, and his name, according to his lawyers, was not expressly mentioned in the operative orders after the Certified True Copy was finally released on Wednesday, November 11.

But this logic is consequential. If the leadership that conducted the ADC presidential primary was essentially invalid, then the primary it conducted is also called into question. That is why news media reports from the judgment concluded that the process that produced Atiku as the ADC presidential candidate for the January 16, 2027 election has been invalidated.

Expectedly, the ADC disagrees. Its lawyer, Kalu Kalu, SAN, argued on national television thus: “The judgment of Honourable Justice Peter Lifu does not in any way void the candidacy of Atiku Abubakar… No portion of that judgment voids the candidacy of Atiku Abubakar and other candidates of the party.” That is now the central legal argument that will be tested at the Court of Appeal.

The ADC filed its notice of appeal on November 6, alongside an application for stay of execution, and has urged INEC not to act until the appeal is determined. INEC, for its part, has taken a cautious approach. Its National Commissioner, Mohammed Haruna, said the Commission would not act until it receives and studies the Certified True Copy. That delay – five days before the CTC was released – itself became a controversy, with ADC candidates protesting at the Federal High Court and petitioning the Chief Judge, Justice John Tsoho.

Two Conflicting Judgments, One Party The crisis is also deepened by another fact: the ADC says it already had a judgment in its favour. An earlier judgment by Justice Musa Liman of the same Federal High Court had, according to the party, affirmed the legitimacy of the Mark-led leadership. The ADC says it relied on that judgment. The country now faces a familiar problem: two judgments from courts of coordinate jurisdiction, pointing in different directions, on the same party leadership tussle.

Can a party or the electoral commission choose which of the two judgments to respect? Only the Court of Appeal – and ultimately the Supreme Court – can resolve which one stands. This development is not new in Nigerian politics. From PDP to APC to Labour Party, internal leadership disputes have repeatedly been a deciding factor regarding who is on the ballot, not the voters, or who the voters actually voted for among warring candidates.

The law has apparently become the new primary election. What does all of this mean on the road to the 2027 governorship election? For President Bola Tinubu and the APC, the judgment is politically convenient, but it may also be legally delicate. It removes – at least temporarily –

  • judgment
  • justice
  • atiku
  • lifu
  • adc
  • national
  • party
  • gombe

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

2027 Elections: ‘Nigerians Have Been Rejecting Him,’ Segun Sowunmi Faults Atiku’s Candidacy
politics

2027 Elections: ‘Nigerians Have Been Rejecting Him,’ Segun Sowunmi Faults Atiku’s Candidacy

A Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) chieftain, Segun Sowunmi, has criticised African Democratic Congress (ADC) presidential candidate Atiku Abubakar’s repeated bids for Nigeria’s presidency, claiming that Nigerians have consistently rejected his ambition at the polls. He further questioned Atiku’s candidacy under the African Democratic Congress (ADC), following a Federal High Court judgment nullifying the leadership of the caretaker committee led by former Senate President David Mark.

Read →
Breaking: Omotosho, Nwite, 10 others sworn in as Appeal Court Justices
crime

Breaking: Omotosho, Nwite, 10 others sworn in as Appeal Court Justices

By Ikechukwu Nnochiri ABUJA – The Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun, on Tuesday swore in 12 new Justices of the Court of Appeal. Among the new appellate court justices whose elevation the National Judicial Council (NJC) recommended at its meeting on May 13 are two Federal High Court judges, Justices James Omotosho and Emeka Nwite, who hitherto handled high-profile cases.

Read →
PPDT gets 18 new members as Judiciary prepares for 2027 elections
politics

PPDT gets 18 new members as Judiciary prepares for 2027 elections

NAIROBI, Kenya, Nov 17 — Chief Justice Martha Koome has called for early preparations to strengthen the resolution of political party disputes ahead of the 2027 General Election. The Registrar of Tribunals, working with the PPDT, the Judiciary Committee on Elections and the Kenya Judiciary Academy, was tasked with developing a comprehensive 2027 readiness plan.

Read →
Opposition Sets A Signing Date, But The Parties Still Want Different Things
politics

Opposition Sets A Signing Date, But The Parties Still Want Different Things

He could not confirm a formal proposal or NDC participation in the reported bilateral Atiku-Makinde negotiations. Talks Continue, Without A Confirmed Concession On Atiku Party spokesman Bolaji Abdullahi and Atiku aide Phrank Shaibu have confirmed opposition engagement, but neither confirmed a specific agreement with Makinde.

Read →