science

World ‘held hostage by oil mafia’ says Panama minister at Cop 31

World ‘held hostage by oil mafia’ says Panama minister at Cop 31

30 countries now signed up to forge new fossil fuel treaty, separate to UN process The world is “being held hostage by the petroleum mafia” and seems unable to break free, Panama’s environment minister has warned, as key issues remain unresolved in the final days of the UN Cop31 climate summit. “We are in love with our kidnappers,” said Juan Carlos Navarro, at a press conference to announce 30 countries were now signed up to forge a new fossil fuel treaty, separate to the UN process.

30 countries now signed up to forge new fossil fuel treaty, separate to UN process

The world is “being held hostage by the petroleum mafia” and seems unable to break free, Panama’s environment minister has warned, as key issues remain unresolved in the final days of the UN Cop31 climate summit.

“We are in love with our kidnappers,” said Juan Carlos Navarro, at a press conference to announce 30 countries were now signed up to forge a new fossil fuel treaty, separate to the UN process. “We love the petroleum guys. We can’t live without them, and they are so smart they have convinced us that they are doing this for our own good.”

Expressing the frustration shared by scores of developing countries and thousands of civil society activists at these talks, he added: “They torture us for our own good, they destroy our planet for our own good. They destroy nature to help us, and they demand our unrequited, endless, unlimited, boundless love. And we are so stupid that we fall for it.”

Nations have only two official days of negotiation left at Cop31 to resolve key issues, such as whether the conference should recognise the need to “transition away from fossil fuels” and how to address the “overshoot” of global temperatures beyond the 1.5C of heating targeted in the Paris agreement.

The Australian presidency of the talks and the Turkish hosts convened a “divan” meeting of ministers on Wednesday evening. Named for the Ottoman Empire’s term for a council or assembly, the aim of the meeting was to make progress on a revised draft of a possible outcome and find compromises on sticking points. Significant dividing lines remain on issues such as climate finance, how to ensure a “just transition” to clean economy jobs for workers in fossil fuels and helping poor countries adapt to the impacts of extreme weather.

The first draft of a “cover decision”, issued on Monday, contained 144 separate items, including several – such as the “transition away from fossil fuels” – that some of the nearly 200 countries at the fortnight-long talks find contentious. There are concerns that the Australian approach of including “everything” in the draft text may result in longer negotiations. A new draft is expected on Thursday morning.

A breakthrough from the “divan” meeting was not expected, but negotiators told the Guardian that countries were working together on compromises. Campaigners feared that the outcome would be feeble, however.

Mohamed Adow, director of the Power Shift Africa thinktank, accused rich countries of offering “crumbs” to a fund for the developing world to adapt to extreme weather. Only $50m has been pledged so far, compared to $135m last year.

“Rich countries are offering crumbs to the adaptation fund, while blocking the negotiations that should provide the money countries need,” he said. “Listening to ministers praise the adaptation fund before giving next to nothing, you have to wonder how they expect it to do the work they say is so important.”

There was anger, too, over the “just transition mechanism”, which is intended to help developing countries ensure workers in high-carbon industries can be retrained or helped, while they grow nascent green industries. “We’re seeing massive steps backwards on adaptation finance and just transition, relative to previous Cops,” said Brandon Wu, director of policy and campaigns at the ActionAid USA charity. “In both cases, the blocking is being led by the EU.”

Irene Vélez Torres, the former Colombian minister who convened talks in Santa Marta in April on the phase-out of fossil fuels, told the Guardian she was worried about a target to generate 35% of final energy from electricity by 2035, which is thought to have the explicit support of at least 60 countries, and the tacit support of more, including China. Like many campaigners, she would like to see provisions that ensure the electricity comes from renewable sources.

“I’m very scared that [the target] is not going to be explicit about clean green energy, because it may imply that they are going to lock us in future dependencies on gas and coal power. If we don’t explicitly declare that the electricity is going to be powered by green and clean energy, we may make a mistake,” she said.

Frustrated with the slow speed of the UN talks, some countries have been using Cop31 to further their own alternatives. Colombia has changed governments since Vélez convened talks on a “transition away from fossil fuels” in April, but the Santa Marta process carries on, with Tuvalu hosting the next meeting.

The Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative, with 30 members, at whose event Navarro was speaking, is another attempt to create a “coalition of the willing” to phase out fossil fuels, as is the Beyond Oil and Gas Alliance.

Ethiopia, which will host the Cop32 meeting next year, is leading a group of nations that want to go further than phasing out fossil fuels. The “group of negative emitters” aim to absorb more carbon than they produce, by using carbon capture technology or growing trees and restoring natural “carbon sinks”, such as wetlands and peatlands.

“Slashing emissions is essential but no longer enough,” said Ani Dasgupta, president of the World Resources Institute thinktank. “We must also actively pull carbon out of the atmosphere, to bring temperatures back down.”

Samuel Addis Alemayehu, Ethiopian ambassador, called for financial help for poor countries to follow through with their plans. “Ethiopia is expanding nature-based solutions [such as tree-planting] and calls for scaled-up support, adequate finance and access to technologies that reduce emissions,” he said.

  • world
  • hostage
  • mafia
  • panama
  • minister
  • oil
  • cop
  • country

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

The Guardian view on climate debt: a vicious cycle the world must break at Cop31
science

The Guardian view on climate debt: a vicious cycle the world must break at Cop31

Yet the Loss and Damage Fund, hailed as a historic breakthrough at the 2022 UN climate summit, has earmarked just $20m for Nepal – less than 5% of the $482m that Kathmandu must pay its external public creditors this year. “The scale of resources needs to increase,” Nepal’s delegation to this year’s UN climate conference drily observed.

Read →
COP 31: African youth urge world leaders to put water at centre of climate adaptation funding
science

COP 31: African youth urge world leaders to put water at centre of climate adaptation funding

The call was made at the ongoing UN climate conference, COP31, in Antalya, Türkiye, where the African Youth Water and Climate Engagement Initiative presented findings from a continent-wide survey on water and climate challenges. The initiative, led by the Green Africa Youth Organisation (GAYO) with support from the Children’s Investment Fund Foundation (CIFF), surveyed 1,209 young people in 51 African countries and held consultations with 984 others across West, Central, East, North and Southern Africa.

Read →
Africa must reject unfunded climate obligations at COP31 — Zanetor
science

Africa must reject unfunded climate obligations at COP31 — Zanetor

African countries should not accept new climate obligations without adequate financial, technological and capacity-building support, Dr Zanetor Agyeman-Rawlings, Minister of Environment, Science and Technology, has said. Dr Agyeman-Rawlings made the call at the African Ministerial Conference on the Environment (AMCEN) High-Level Ministerial Consultative Meeting, held on the margins of COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye.

Read →
We’re negotiating livelihoods, not climate – Africa presses for climate finance at COP31
science

We’re negotiating livelihoods, not climate – Africa presses for climate finance at COP31

Yet, as world leaders and negotiators gather in Antalya, Türkiye, for the second week of the UN Climate Change Conference (COP31), African representatives say the continent’s ability to respond to these impacts will depend largely on whether developed countries deliver the financial commitments needed to support climate action. The Chair of the African Group of Negotiators (AGN), Nana Dr. Antwi-Boasiako Amoah, made this point during an engagement with African civil society organisations, where he briefed them on the state of negotiations and the continent’s priorities for the remainder of the…

Read →